Job evaluation is a basic but significant function of human resource management (HRM). Every organization has several jobs, and the goal of job evaluation is to compare jobs with each other in order to create a pay structure that is fair, equitable, and consistent for everyone. The job evaluation process ensures that everyone is paid their worth. It also notes that different jobs have varying levels of entry and performance requirements. Essentially, job evaluation in HRM is the process of determining and quantifying the value of jobs. 

What is the Job Evaluation Process?

The job evaluation process systematically scores and compares jobs along dimensions of job worth (effort, responsibility and complexity, importance, skills, and working conditions of the job). It is a tool to compare jobs and classify them into appropriate pay ranges. The job evaluation process consists of job analysis, job descriptions, and the arrival of pay equity.

The job evaluation process ensures that the organization’s pay system is equitable, understandable, legally defensible, and competitive. In simple words, Job evaluations are used to attract desirable candidates and retain high-performing employees through fair and equitable pay scales.

Features of Job Evaluation

The main features of job evaluation are:

• Assess jobs, not people – The job evaluation system mainly focuses on the job itself and not the candidate occupying the role.
• Basis for Wage Negotiation – It provides objective data for wage negotiation. Job evaluation does not design wage structure. Instead, it reduces the differences in wages and rationalizes the system.
• Expert-driven – At an organization, Job evaluation is done by a trained professional who can skillfully access the job content accurately and impartially.

• Determines the value of the job – By evaluating skill levels, responsibilities, and other job factors, the value of a job within the organization is confined.
• Enhance Employee Satisfaction and Productivity – Job evaluation improves fairness in compensation, which in turn boosts employee morale and productivity.

Objectives of Job Evaluation

Job evaluation determines the relative contributions that the performance of different jobs makes toward the realization of organizational objectives. The objectives of job evaluation can be understood as:

Wage and salary fixation

Wage and salary fixation is based on the relative contributions of different jobs and not on the basis of who the job holders are. Firstly, it is important to identify the likely contributions of different jobs. Job evaluation provides information about the worth of a job based on its contribution to the achievement of organizational effectiveness.

Restructuring job hierarchy

Job hierarchy is all about arranging different types of jobs in the order of their importance, either in an ascending or descending manner. Job hierarchy can sometimes create problems because it is too lengthy and increases the number of levels in an organization. Essentially, organizations today prefer a flat structure to a tall one. Therefore, a job evaluation is preferred because it can reduce the number of job levels by merging closely related jobs together.

Overcoming anomalies

When done periodically and objectively, job evaluation can overcome anomalies that develop in an organization over a period of time in compensation management. The following anomalies can be overcome by job evaluation:

• High wages are being paid to people who hold positions that don’t require great skill, effort, and responsibility.
• Paying beginners less than what they are entitled to is against what is required of them.
• Giving a raise to people whose performance does not justify the raise.
• Deciding the compensation based on seniority rather than ability.
• Paying varied wages for the same or closely related jobs and positions.
• Paying unequal salaries based on discrimination of race, sex, religion, or political differences.

Important Components of Job Evaluation

Job evaluation plays a vital role in Human Resource Management as it greatly impacts several aspects of human resources and the overall goals of the organization.

• Skill Requirements – The basic thing to mark is the level of education, experience, training, and technical expertise required for the job.
• Roles and Responsibilities – The key responsibilities and the decision-making authority of the designated role in the company. Roles with higher responsibilities deserve higher compensation.
• Workspace – Job evaluation has an impact on the workplace location, timing, and conditions, such as safety, cleanliness, and other necessary facilities.

• Effort – Both physical and mental efforts are required to carry out the key responsibilities of the role. The role is marked as valuable to the candidates depending on the amount of physical and mental health required. 
• Impressive Tasks – Nobody looks for a role where one needs to repeat the same work every day. So, complex jobs with maximum responsibilities and higher authority with higher salaries are preferred the most.
• Impact on Organizational Goals – The contribution of the candidate for the designated role to the overall success of the organization. Positions that are linked to business outcomes or revenue generation are considered more valuable.

Steps in the Job Evaluation Process 

Job evaluations follow the following steps:

1. Choosing the Right Evaluation Method – The first thing that the organization must determine is an appropriate job evaluation method. There are various evaluation methods, such as ranking, classification, point factor, or factor comparison, depending on their needs.

2. Data Collection – Collecting precise details about the job through methods like questionnaires, interviews, job descriptions, and site visits. This ensures transparency and assists in understanding the full scope of the job.

3. Job Description Review – Each job description is reviewed thoroughly to ensure it clearly states the responsibilities and accountabilities associated with the position. When necessary, an organization can make adjustments to the description of the role.

4. Job Scale – The next step is evaluating each job based on the key components of the job evaluation mentioned above. This can be done through any suitable methods, and a point system could be a better choice where each factor is assigned a score.

5. Aligning Pay Structure – Once the job evaluation is done, the ranked jobs are connected to the organization’s existing payment system, or a new pay system is designed based on the evaluation.

6. Review and Modification – The job evaluation plan is occasionally reviewed and revised to ensure it stays appropriate and aligned with varying job roles, responsibilities, and market conditions.

Types of Job Evaluation Methods

There are various methods to evaluate jobs, each with its distinctive approach:

• Ranking Method – Jobs are ranked depending on their comparative value corresponding to others. This is a simple yet subjective method.
• Point Factor Method – Specific aspects such as skills, effort, responsibility, and working circumstances are given points, which are then summed to define the value of the designated role.
• Classification Method – Jobs are categorized into predefined grades or classes. This method is generally used in government jobs.
• Factor Comparison Method – This method considers jobs by comparing factors across different positions, giving monetary values to each factor.
• Competitive Market Research Method – Job evaluation is performed based on external market analysis to confirm that the organization’s pay system is competitive.

Advantages of Job Evaluation

Job evaluation offers multiple benefits for both workers and organizations:

• Announces Pay Equity – Assures that workers are paid based on the value of their work rather than individual factors or biases.
• Assists in Attracting Talent – The transparency in the pay structure can help draw high-quality candidates.
• Employee Satisfaction – Fair pay can satisfy employees, which can improve productivity and reduce turnover.
• Streamlines Job Structures – It helps manage jobs logically to improve decision-making and working efficiency.

How Job Evaluation Differs from Related Concepts

It’s important to differentiate what is job evaluation from related terms such as job analysis and merit rating:

• Job Analysis and Job Evaluation: While job analysis collects data about a job’s duties and requirements, job evaluation utilizes that collected data to define the job’s value within the association. Comprehending job analysis and job evaluation helps clarify their typical goals.
• Merit Rating and Job Evaluation: Merit rating considers the performance employee, while job evaluation assesses the job’s relative worth. 

The Value of Job Evaluation in Modern HRM

The aim of job evaluation in HRM is to remove possible pay inequities. For instance, if an employee is being paid significantly more and given better benefits than someone in a similar role, then it is a pay inequity. Usually, job evaluation is done through a combination of internal assessment of the roles in the company and external market research.

FAQ